The courts as communities framework is built on the idea of community aspects in courts leading to regional sentencing disparities. Correspondingly, numerous studies have found between-court variation in sentencing but its backgrounds have remained largely unknown due to limited sentencing data. The aim of the current study is to address court communities and local sentencing norms in the under-researched continental European context. Interviews with 14 Finnish district judges were analysed using thematic analysis. The findings revealed local elements in the application of case law: judges often follow local legal practice and discuss legal practice in their court communities with colleagues. The local application of case law can indeed create risks of differences in sentencing between courts, although, correspondingly, interaction between judges regarding case law can also unify the application of the law. It is suggested that more national-level interaction for judges could be provided.



