Originally intended and conceptualised as an institution exclusively available to same-sex couples, civil partnerships have been revised, repurposed and reimagined following the regime’s recent extension to mixed-sex couples. The belief that civil partnerships are devoid of the negative connotations associated with marriage or lack a social script undoubtedly fuelled this process. Many might see this change as a victory for equality and inclusivity, but the process of reform exposes problematic revisionism and generates fundamental questions about the significance and purpose of relationship formalisation. This article confronts such questions through discerning three stages in the evolution of civil partnerships with them characterised as a means of obtaining legal protection, a form of protest and, more recently, as a status offering the potential of personalisation. This article argues that while the absence of social script might suggest scope for innovation, creativity and the disruption of marital norms, such claims should be approached cautiously.