This paper aims to provide a new perspective on the reasons why some European tort law reforms are not successful, by exploring the influence of evidence issues on such reforms. Focusing on the 2017 and 2020 French tort law reform projects, the paper tests the following hypothesis: whereas substantive tort law reforms logically focus on substantive matters, some of the most acute problems faced by users and practitioners are evidential in nature. Moreover, whereas substantive law reforms address highly controversial topics, evidence law may be seen as being less politically oriented. These two features may therefore explain why the French tort law reform did not manage to materialize, as it was notperceived as a means to resolve salient issues, and dwelled on political controversies. If this hypothesis is ascertained, it may advocate for a strategical shift as regards future tort law reforms, in France and other European countries. Namely, drafting evidence law reforms, either general or applied to tort law, may encounter fewer political hurdles while having a high improvement impact on actual tort law issues. Before reaching this conclusion, this paper first underlines the existing discrepancy between the last French reform project and actual evidence issues. Second, it compares the political aspects of the project’s key proposals with the seemingly neutral nature of evidence issues. Last, the paper advocates for a shift in how tort law reforms are designed, towards a more integrated approach addressing both substantial and evidence issues.



