By analysing and comparing the remedial response of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (ICtHR) in cases involving systemic violence against women, I argue that the dissimilarity in the formulation and selection of remedies between those courts responds to their differing - almost opposite - understanding of remedies. The ECtHR: (i) adopts a rights essentialism approach that separates the rights discourse from the remedial reasoning; (ii) sharply distinguishes individual remedies from structural ones; and (iii) exercises a noticeably strong remedial discretion. However, the ICtHR: (i) embraces the full remedy rule approach, which states that every right entails an effective remedy; (ii) considers that the principle of restitutio in integrum requires effective remedies regardless of whether they are individual or systemic; and (iii) adopts a rule-based remedial discretion that assigns minimal weight to other principles that could impose constraints on remedies.